Feedback
ยท
Make expanded traits more compact (implemented)
Currently, when you expand a trait, it expands a lot. That's a problem for showing/hiding them, because upon expanding, the top spacing makes the trait jump from beneath the cursor to further down.
It might be better off if it was more compact, like so.
It would take a profile (which I picked at random from the global list) that looks like this when expanded, and make it look like this instead. With the lack of horizontal lines around the place, it looks neater, and with the preferences indented it makes it easier to distinguish them from the rest of the content. If you want to distinguish them further, add a border. (That's a left-margin and left-padding of 1rem each, with a left border and a 1rem bottom-left border radius.)
meta info
endorsement points: 111
created: 17 January 15 at 03:45 AM (build: 1/14/2015 7:39 PM alpha)
closed: 20 January 15 at 01:20 AM (build: 1/20/2015 1:16 AM alpha)
There might be something to indenting the preferences, but removing the borders actually seems to cause visual confusion for some people. Not too long ago I only had a bottom border on each expanded item (instead of bottom + top) and people were visually confusing an expanded trait with a non-expanded trait just above it.
Huh, if it weren't for the pictures I probably wouldn't have chimed in on this! I was somebody who was confused when borders were bottom-only. However I personally find zero borders to be far far nicer to look at. I didn't expect that.
Bottom-borders were confusing to me because when items without borders were interspersed with items that had borders, it visually clustered them together into "groups" that had nothing to do with each other. But that's not happening here.
So my opinion: No borders > double borders > bottom borders
Trying to imagine what other people might have trouble with. The one downside I see compared to having borders, is that it may become more difficult to tell which trait the preferences (the hearts) belong to. No idea how badly though.
I was also very confused about the borders at first but this mockup basically shows that it looks a LOT less confusing than I thought it would. The key here is probably the indentation which makes the borders not feel very necessary anymore.
Since the response to this has been overwhelming positive from users, people can now endorse this to show much they'd want it.
Got something to say?
Why don't you register and participate?
Litphoria has a unique community feedback system, where the community decides what profile options are available, and what order new features are developed.